TradingView Black Friday: up to 80% off annual plans, 23 November to 1 December. See the dates and the best plan

Kagels Trading
Topics

Volume Profile Strategy: 3 Setups Backtested on SPY

Contents
  1. Volume profile strategy in 30 seconds
  2. What is a volume profile strategy?
  3. The three setups from the video
  4. How I tested the setups
  5. Results: what 1,005 SPY trades show
  6. The cross-check in QQQ
  7. Does the filter from the video matter?
  8. Robustness: how much the result depends on details
  9. Long vs short and the effect of the trend
  10. What the test means for your trading
  11. Limits of this test
  12. Pros and cons of the three setups
  13. Conclusion: good levels, no finished system
  14. Frequently asked questions about the volume profile strategy
  15. About the author

A volume profile setup that looks clean in a few chart examples can still be close to a coin flip over six years. The popular guide I tested shows three setups, each with a stop and a target of 2R, and most of its examples reach the target. I turned the three setups into fixed rules and ran them on 1,403 trading days of the S&P 500 ETF SPY.

This article shows the rules, the results and what they mean for your own trading. You will see how often the target was really reached, how much the result depends on a single setting, and what a second market, the Nasdaq 100 ETF QQQ, adds. This article follows our editorial policy.

Volume profile strategy in 30 seconds

  • Three setups tested: POC bounce, value area reversal and value area breakout, each based on the prior day’s profile, as taught in the video.
  • No reliable edge: in SPY the average per trade was −0.17R, −0.02R and +0.02R. For every setup in both markets, the range of plausible results includes zero.
  • The 2R target is rare: only about one trade in seven reached it. About half ended at the session close without hitting stop or target.
  • Fragile POC result: with 59, 60 or 61 rows the POC bounce in SPY gave +0.01R, −0.17R or −0.12R per trade.
  • My view: use the profile for levels and context, not as a complete trading system.

What is a volume profile strategy?

A volume profile strategy is a set of trading rules that uses the levels of a volume profile, mainly the point of control (POC), value area high (VAH) and value area low (VAL), to decide where to enter, where to place the stop and where to take profit.

The profile itself only shows where trading took place, not where price will go. The volume profile guide explains the levels in detail. A strategy turns them into decisions, which is why it can be tested: its rules say exactly when you are in and when you are out.

The three setups from the video

The setups come from a popular guide by the YouTube channel Data Trader. The video “The BEST Volume Profile Trading Guide You’ll EVER FIND” from September 2026 had more than 945,000 views on November 16, 2026. In our Google search of the same day it appeared in the AI Overview for “volume profile”, in the US and in Germany.

All three setups use the profile of the previous session, not of the current day. The video draws a fixed range volume profile over the full prior session with 60 rows and a 70 percent value area, and uses the levels for the next day. Every trade has a stop and a target of two times the risk (2R).

Setup Prior day Trigger
POC bounce closed outside value price touches the POC and is rejected
Reversal closed inside value close outside, then back inside value
Breakout any strong break, pullback holds, break of structure

The video presents the three setups as one system. If price does not return to value after a reversal signal, a breakout setup may follow in the other direction. The video shows one such day, where a 1R loss is followed by a 2R win. Its other examples are winning trades, and it gives no count over many days.

How I tested the setups

I used the same data as in my volume profile test: SPY, 5-minute bars of the regular session from 9:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Eastern Time. The bars come from Twelve Data with exchange volume and cover November 20, 2020 to October 15, 2026. For each day I built the prior day’s profile with exactly 60 rows between the session low and high and a 70 percent value area. Each bar’s volume is spread evenly over its range.

The video leaves several details open, so I had to fix them as rules. The values below are my reading. Where a choice could matter, I tested other values as well (see robustness).

  • Time frame: 15-minute bars as in the video, built from the 5-minute data. Entry at the close of the signal bar, never on the last bar of the day.
  • Exit: stop or target of 2R, otherwise at the session close. If stop and target fall in the same bar, I count the stop (the cautious choice).
  • POC bounce: the bar touches the prior POC coming from one side and closes back on that side as a bearish (or bullish) candle. Stop 1 cent beyond the POC or the bar’s extreme. One trade per day.
  • Reversal: a bar closes outside the value area, a later bar closes back inside. Stop 1 cent beyond the extreme since the break. Several trades per day are allowed, as in the video.
  • Breakout: a close at least 25 percent of the value area width beyond VAH (or VAL). The pullback must come within 10 percent of that edge, and a close more than 25 percent back inside the value area cancels the setup. The entry is a close beyond the extreme before the pullback, the break of structure. Stop 1 cent beyond the pullback extreme, one trade per day, long and short alike.
  • Costs and data: a flat 1 cent per share on entry and on exit, no extra model for spread or slippage. A gap through the stop or target is filled at the next bar’s open. NYSE half days and days with gaps in the volume data are not used, neither as profile day nor as trading day. Besides the half days with incomplete data, that removed 12 otherwise complete days in SPY.

Results are measured in R, the risk of each trade. A result of +0.10R means you earned on average a tenth of what you risked. That makes trades with small and large stops comparable and fits the risk-reward ratio logic of the video.

Results: what 1,005 SPY trades show

None of the three setups produced a reliable profit in SPY. The POC bounce lost on average, the reversal ended near zero and the breakout slightly positive. For all three, the 95 percent range of the average includes zero, so the data shows no statistically reliable result in either direction.

Setup Trades Per trade Total
POC 131 −0.17R −22.5R
Reversal 613 −0.02R −12.1R
Breakout 261 +0.02R +5.1R
All three 1,005 −0.03R −29.4R

The ranges show how little the averages say. I resampled whole trading days 2,000 times. For the POC bounce the range runs from −0.40R to +0.05R per trade, for the reversal from −0.10R to +0.07R, for the breakout from −0.09R to +0.15R (+0.145R before rounding). With 131 trades in six years, the POC bounce also has a small sample.

How the trades ended shows where the problem lies. The share of winning trades was 32.1 percent for the POC bounce, 42.1 percent for the reversal and 47.5 percent for the breakout. The exits looked like this:

Setup Target Stop Close
POC 22.1% 65.6% 12.2%
Reversal 13.1% 37.8% 49.1%
Breakout 12.3% 33.7% 54.0%
All three 14.0% 40.4% 45.6%

A 2R target inside one session was often simply too far. With a median stop of $1.86 for the reversal and $1.93 for the breakout in SPY, the target needed a move of almost four dollars on the same day. That is why about half of these trades ended at the close, often with a small gain, which also makes the win rate look better than the result.

The cross-check in QQQ

In the Nasdaq 100 ETF the same rules did better, but still without a reliable edge. Over the same period, with 1,397 trading days, the POC bounce gave +0.15R per trade, the reversal 0.00R and the breakout +0.09R.

QQQ Trades Per trade Range
POC 132 +0.15R −0.08 to +0.39
Reversal 611 0.00R −0.08 to +0.09
Breakout 253 +0.09R −0.03 to +0.21

The breakout is the only setup with a positive average in both markets. In QQQ its range comes close to zero but still includes it. The 2R target came in 15.1 percent of all QQQ trades, almost the same as in SPY.

The POC bounce shows the opposite sign in the two markets. A loss of 0.17R per trade in SPY and a gain of 0.15R in QQQ, with the same rules and the same period and wide ranges in both, show that a POC edge is not robustly proven in this test.

Does the filter from the video matter?

In my data, the filter did not help consistently. The video says the POC bounce only works when the prior day closed outside the value area. I ran the same setup without that rule and with the opposite rule. The table shows the average per trade, with the number of trades in brackets.

Prior day SPY QQQ
outside value (video) −0.17R (131) +0.15R (132)
no filter −0.09R (459) −0.06R (485)
inside value −0.06R (328) −0.13R (353)

In QQQ the filter pointed in the right direction, in SPY it did not. In SPY the video’s version was even the worst of the three. A rule that helps in one index and hurts in the other is not a reliable filter.

For the reversal setup, the filter made almost no difference. With the video’s rule (prior close inside value) the average was −0.02R in SPY, without the rule −0.03R, and with the opposite rule −0.06R. The idea is close to the 80% rule, which I checked separately in my auction market theory test: the far edge of value was reached in about half the cases, not in 80 percent.

Robustness: how much the result depends on details

A single row more or less changed the POC result from break-even to a clear loss. That is the clearest warning in this test, because a real edge should survive a small change in the settings. The base case uses 15-minute bars, 60 rows and a 2R target. “Exit at 1R” and “Exit at 3R” change only the target. Values are the average result per trade in R.

SPY POC Reversal Breakout
Base −0.17 −0.02 +0.02
59 rows +0.01 +0.02 −0.01
61 rows −0.12 0.00 −0.03
100 rows −0.09 +0.01 +0.02
5 min −0.12 −0.02 +0.03
Exit at 1R −0.09 −0.07 −0.01
Exit at 3R −0.09 −0.03 +0.04
No cost −0.14 −0.01 +0.03

The POC level moves with the row grid, and the bounce trades depend on that exact level. In QQQ, 59, 60 and 61 rows gave +0.07R, +0.15R and +0.02R. My first test version used a slightly shifted price grid and showed +0.08R for the POC bounce in SPY. TradingView builds its rows with its own tick rounding, so your chart can differ from mine in exactly this way.

Costs matter most for the POC bounce, because its stops are small. The median stop was only $0.77, about 0.14 percent of the price. Two cents of costs per round trip already cost about 0.03R per trade.

A stricter breakout helped a little, a looser one hurt. With a breakout of at least 50 percent of the value area width, the average rose to +0.06R (116 trades). With only 10 percent, it fell to −0.02R (452 trades).

Long vs short and the effect of the trend

Long and short trades gave very different results, possibly because of the trend. In SPY, long breakout trades gave +0.17R and short breakout trades −0.14R. The uptrend from 2020 to 2026 may explain part of that, but this test cannot separate the trend from the setup itself.

The reversal setup in SPY shows the opposite pattern. Short trades after a return from above the value area gave +0.03R, long trades after a return from below −0.08R. In QQQ, long and short reversal trades were both close to zero.

The results also change a lot from year to year. The reversal in SPY made +17.7R in 2023 and 2024 together and lost 29.4R in 2025 and 2026. Anyone who tests only one or two years can come to almost any conclusion.

What the test means for your trading

The volume profile is useful, but these three setups are not a ready-made system. In my data, the levels from the prior day did not give a reliable edge on their own, at least not with these simple entry and exit rules.

  • Use the levels as context: the prior POC, VAH and VAL are good places to watch. What happens there, for example in the order flow, decides whether a trade makes sense.
  • Check the target: a fixed 2R target inside one session was rarely reached. Plan where the next level lies, and ask whether price can get there today.
  • Do not trust one exact level: the POC result changed with a single row. Treat the POC as a zone, not as a line to the cent.
  • Test your own version: small details change the result. Write your rules down and backtest them before you risk money, for example with the tools in our TradingView backtesting guide.
  • Size your risk for the drawdown: the reversal setup alone had a drawdown of 35R in SPY. At 1 percent risk per trade, that is a loss of roughly 30 percent of the account. Our guide to position sizing shows how to plan for that.

Limits of this test

The rules are my reading of the video, not an official version. Words such as “significant break”, “holds near the level” or “confirmation” leave room. I chose clear values and tested the most important alternatives, but another trader may draw the lines differently and see other results.

The profile is an approximation from 5-minute bars. Each bar’s volume is spread evenly over its range, so the POC and value area can differ from TradingView’s profile, which uses lower time frame data and its own row grid. As the row test shows, that difference can change the POC result.

The statistics have limits too. The ranges come from a bootstrap of whole trading days and assume that days are independent. I did not compare the setups with random entries, and the test covers two US index ETFs, not futures, forex or single stocks.

Past results say nothing certain about the future. The test is a hypothetical evaluation with a flat cost of one cent per share and side, and with entries at the close of the signal bar, which you may not get in live trading.

Pros and cons of the three setups

The setups have real strengths, as long as you know what the test showed. The list sums up the design of the setups and my results in SPY and QQQ.

What speaks for the setups

  • Clear rules: each setup has a defined entry, stop and target, which makes it testable.
  • Sensible levels: the prior day’s POC and value area are levels that many traders watch.
  • Breakout slightly positive: it was the only setup above zero in both markets.
  • Short stop distance: the median stop of the POC bounce was only $0.77. Your money risk still depends on the position size.

What speaks against them

  • No reliable edge: in both markets every range included zero.
  • Target too far: the 2R target came in only about one trade out of seven.
  • Fragile: one row more or less changed the POC result from break-even to a clear loss.
  • Few examples: the video shows a handful of charts, not a count over many days.

Conclusion: good levels, no finished system

My test does not confirm that these three volume profile setups give an edge on their own. Over almost six years of SPY, with a cross-check in QQQ, no setup showed a reliable average result, the 2R target was reached in only one trade out of seven, and the POC bounce changed sign between markets and with a single row.

The test does not say that the volume profile is useless. The prior POC and value area are good reference points, and the breakout was slightly positive in both markets. But the edge, if there is one, comes from what you add: the context of the higher time frame, the reaction at the level and a realistic target. Start with the levels, and test your own rules before you trust any setup.

Frequently asked questions about the volume profile strategy

What is the best volume profile strategy?

In my test, no setup was reliably profitable. The breakout was the only one with a positive average in both markets, +0.02R per trade in SPY and +0.09R in QQQ. Even there, the range of plausible results still included zero.

How do you trade the point of control?

The common approach is to wait for price to return to the prior day’s POC and look for a rejection there. In my test this POC bounce lost 0.17R per trade in SPY and gained 0.15R in QQQ. The result also changed with a single row of the profile, so treat the POC as a zone.

Does the volume profile strategy work for day trading?

The levels are made for day trading, but the simple setups did not show a reliable edge in my test. About half of all trades ended at the session close without reaching stop or target, because a 2R target inside one day was often too far. Day traders should plan targets around the next level.

Which time frame is best for volume profile trading?

The video uses 15-minute bars, and in my test 5-minute bars did not change the overall picture. On 5-minute bars, the POC bounce in SPY gave −0.12R per trade and the breakout +0.03R. The profile itself always comes from the prior session.

What settings should I use for the volume profile?

The video uses 60 rows and a value area of 70 percent. In my test the POC bounce gave +0.01R with 59 rows and −0.17R with 60 rows in SPY. Keep your settings fixed, test them, and do not expect the POC to the exact cent.

What is the 80% rule in volume profile trading?

The 80% rule says that after price returns into the prior value area, it crosses to the other side 80 percent of the time. In my auction market theory test with SPY, the far edge was reached in about half the cases. The reversal setup in this article is a similar idea and stayed near zero on average.

This article is market education, not investment advice. The backtest is a hypothetical evaluation of past data and says nothing certain about future results.

A German edition of this article is available on kagels-trading.de.

← All articles